chestnut oak   Fores-@aol.com
  Jan 27, 2004 19:41 PST 
ENTS:

Has any work been done to determine how long chestnut oak lives or how large
its' maximum size is.

In western Massachusetts and southern Vermont where I first encountered CO is
was mostly a crooked, scrubby tree on very poor sites.

In central West Virginia, left over old growth chestnut oak is a regular
component in many private woodlands with individuals between 9' and 12' CBH not
uncommon.

The tree was never favored for timber so it is often the largest (diameter)
individual tree species encountered on private woodlands. Because it grows
exceptionally slow, trees as small as 24" in diameter can be in excess of 230
years old. I have counted the rings on many trees that were over 330 years old.

I have often wondered just how ancient some of the 14-15' CBH "old warriors"
I have encountered may be.

In some of the better growing sites for chestnut oak the trees can have 50
feet of clean bole and run up to 110 feet tall. However, if the CO is 110'
tall, red oak is at least 120' on the same site. The fattest chestnut oaks are
usually under 90' tall.

Any insights from around the boonies would be appreciated.

Russ Richardson

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/species/sp_threads/chestnut_oak1.htm 

Invasive Species   Fores-@aol.com
  Nov 06, 2003 08:00 PST 
ENTS

I have far too much to say on the subject of invasives and have read
the past posts with great interest.......maybe I can gather my thoughts on
invasives at some point but the subject has me so concerned and worried that I
simply have not figured out how to deal with it. In WV we have a serious
invasion of Tree of Heaven and royal Pawlonia underway as well as scattered patches
of kudzu. Right now, our hardwood forests are under assault by one of the
most serious vegetative invasions ever experienced, Japanese stilt grass. It
was not discovered in WV until 1990, by 1995 is was in all 55 counties of the
state. It grows into all disturbed land including, game trails, hiking trails,
highways, power lines, logging roads and stream banks. On land in Crummies
Creek that was clearcut following the February 2003 ice storm the stilt grass
grew over 6' tall this year covering all of the tops of harvested trees and
shaded out (and already killed) the regeneration. Stilt grass has a thatch that
takes at least three years to decompose (compared to most tree leaves that are
gone in 18 months) and the dried thatch burns like gasoline.......not
something you want in the understory or a quality hardwood forest.

Russ Richardson

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/invasives/invasive_species.htm 

Sassafras    Fores-@aol.com
   Sep 13, 2003 04:28 PDT 
Bob:

In many areas of WV, especially areas where there was past farming activity,
sassafras can be a very common pioneer species. It really isn't favored for
timber...although its lumber has a grain that makes it an excellent replacement
for American chestnut in old furniture or antique restoration projects.

Although I never encountered sassafras in MA larger than small crooked poles,
I have encountered it in the woods of WV up to 30" DBH and 100+ feet
tall....28" DBH is the biggest one at Crummies Creek.

Anyway, it seems like roads and skid trails are always being built through
patches of sassafras and the smell that exudes from the ground when a bulldozer
passes through a patch of sassafras is one of the few truly delicious smells
you are ever likely to encounter on a logging job....I would rate it along with
the farming equivalent of fresh mowed hay...the only difference is that the
sassafras smell dissipates in a few minutes while the fresh hay smell can
linger for a couple hours.

Russ

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/species/sp_threads/favorite_trees.htm 

Re: sassafras habitat   Fores-@aol.com
  Feb 10, 2004 04:28 PST 
Dale:

Sassafras is an extremely common pioneer species in abandoned farmland in WV
and can be found on nearly all sites and growing conditions. The shortest,
poorest form and lowest vigor trees are normally found mixed with Virginia pine
and red maple on moderately sloping soils with a heavy clay content and the
soils in those cases tend to be acid.

On Mesic soils that were cleared for farming where there is a combination of
poplar, basswood, slippery elm and cucumber, sassafras can grow very tall and
rival several other tree species for dominance. On the most neutral of soils,
sassafras seems to grow to the tallest and largest diameter of the trees I've
encountered (up to 30" DBH--94" CBH).

In New England, I rarely encountered sassafras much larger that 8" in
diameter and 40' tall.

Russ Richardson

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/species/sp_threads/sassafras_habitat.htm 

Harvest History   Fores-@aol.com
  Jan 27, 2004 15:54 PST 
John:

When a woodlot is highgraded, especially when the process is repeated, the
retards are generally the ones left to reproduce and the impact of having the
genetically superior trees removed will rapidly show a decline in the vigor and
diversity of the species present with noncommercial species becoming dominant.
A highgraded woods will still look highgraded fifty years after the fact and
only silvicultural intervention will likely change the course of such a
dysgenic development.

The best example I can think of is an area on private land near Hawley State
Forest. In that property there was an exceptionally large old sugar maple
that had a severe crook and twist in the bole about 25 feet up. Upon looking the
property over I was encountering sugar maple trees of a variety of diameters
that displayed the same type of defect. Although the first thought I had was
ice damage, that theory rapidly died as I ran out of reasons to explain how
every sugar maple in that area had a crook in a similar height above the ground.
It really took me back when I came into a nearly pure sugar maple stand that
ranged from 4" saplings to 20" sawtimber and all the sugar maples had the
same shaped crook at the same height....none of the ash, red maple or red oak in
the area had any similar feature.

Finally, in certain ways, highgrading has not been as serious a threat to the
forests as it has become in the past 35 years. Up until the late 1960s more
timber was cut by portable sawmills that moved onto properties and basically
cut everything that would make a "buggy whip." Until that time, many areas had
bridges and roads that could not be traveled by the heavy "modern" log trucks
with self loaders and the only was to get the material out of the woods was a
few boards at a time on a one ton farm truck. In those situations, the
harvesting was nearly always a clearcut (or close to it) and the forest that
regenerated often developed into some of the best even aged woodland we have today.

With the eventual arrival of the large stationary sawmills with permanent
locations, trucking unprocessed logs to the mills became such an expense that all
sorts of economic decisions were being made in the woods that never took
place before and all sorts of low value, junky wood that was formerly utilized
became the foundation many of our current privately owned forests.

Unfortunately, this trend, as Joe has eloquently described and ranted on
repeatedly appears to be expanding.

When I participated in Earth Day 1 over a third of a century ago, there is no
way I would have expected people to gradually become more stupid towards the
way they treat the forest. It is really unfortunate to say but I must agree
with Joe in saying that foresters are the greatest threat to truly sustainable
forestry.

Russ Richardson

----original post-----

  • I am wondering about the difference between stands on similar sites, and
    similar age profile (last harvest date the same, or something) but
    different past history with respect to type of harvest. My supposition
    is that sites with more frequent high grading would have a sort of
    handicap when it comes to tree growth. I also suppose factors like seed
    life, shade tolerance, browsing and pasturing, erosion, and yes,
    forestry would be components of the effect. But there would be a certain
    probability when it comes to offspring trees succeeding to the canopy
    that would increase with each successive treatment over time for the
    type of trees left behind after a harvest. With high grading, this site
    would have a disadvantage over time, but after how long?

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/fieldtrips/mass/mount_peak.htm

black locust   Fores-@aol.com
  Nov 23, 2003 18:01 PST 
Bob:

In all of my travels, I have not seen black locust the likes of which grow in
the Dummerston and Putney, Vermont area.

The general Putney area is where many western Massachusetts and southern
Vermont apple growers traditionally got locust posts for the deer fences they
installed around their orchards.

Given the size of some of the locusts along the road sides, I can only
imagine what could be back in the woods.

In West Virginia, black locust can be a common pioneer species but it is
disease prone and often wrecked by grape vines. It is only on rare sites where
you will see locust over 20" DBH. It is not uncommon for trees to reach 80 or
90 feet but taller trees are usually only a function of competetion.

I am reasonably certain that I regularly see older black locust in New
England as a casual and infrequent visitor than I encounter on almost daily forays
into the West Virginia woods.

Russ

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/species/sp_threads/black_locust1.htm

Re: black locust   Fores-@aol.com
  Nov 23, 2003 18:53 PST 
Bob:

In WV Locust is more prized for fence posts and rails than almost anything
else.

Small sawtimber trees 14-16" DBH are often sawn for naturally rot resistant
decking lumber.

Hickory is favored for firewood with localized and highly variable oak
preferences.

In much of the state, Osage orange is not native and quite scarce and I have
never heard of anyone cutting it for firewood.

Russ

----original post-----

A question that comes to mind about the species is: do people in WV use black locust for fuel and if they do what do they say about its properties? I have read that from a BTU standpoint, black locust ranks second only to osage orange, outperforming hickory and white oak.

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/species/sp_threads/black_locust1.htm 

Salvage Logging   Fores-@aol.com
  Oct 03, 2004 04:58 PDT 
Ernie:

I think that one of the most significant aspects of salvage logging in
previously undisturbed forest such as an old growth area would be the introduction
of invasive species of plants that arrive at the site in the mud and dirt on
the logging equipment. My own best guess is that 30 years after a major
disturbance in an a virgin or old growth patch of woods is that some essence of
the "old growth" nature of the place will still be present (if nothing else
because of the massive stems in a horizontal position) but if it has been
salvaged it will look like woods that was salvaged 30 years ago.   In all of my
experience with salvage logging only the best or most valuable trees are
removed and it often a more complete high-grade than Joe Zorzin could ever imagine.
Salvage logging is for the betterment of the landowner and not necessarily
for the betterment of the land.

Russ Richardson

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/threads/salvage_logging.htm 

Re: Bees and Trees    Fores-@aol.com
   Aug 20, 2003 20:01 PDT 
ENTS:

In the forests of West Virginia we have several tree species that honey bees
will work hard.

Yellow poplar flowers are large and can be flowerings like we had this year
can be intense enough to give the canopy of stands a yellowish white tinge.

Many people in Appalachia place their bee stands in the woods to coincide
with the flowering of both yellow poplar and basswood.

The basswood flowers are small, but extremely fragrant and the hum of bees
working a full bloom basswood can easily be heard from more than 100 feet away
from the base of the tree.

The honey produced by basswood has a distinctly different taste from that of
poplar honey and the variation in the color of the honey from the different
tree species can be significant.

Serious bee keepers will try to prevent their bees from making honey when the
oaks are flowering.

Since the arrival of the mites, my encounters with wild honey bees has
dropped from a weekly experience to now, not at all.

There seem to plenty of native pollinators to pick up the slack because we
still get lots of seed and mast.

Russ Richardson
Re: Bees and Trees    Fores-@aol.com
   Aug 21, 2003 04:27 PDT 
Bob:

It took only two or three years for the mites to pretty much wipe out the
wild honey bees. At Crummies Creek, we had at least one bee tree for every 100
acres of forest with the locations of many individual bee trees specifically
known by local residents who would often cut down the trees for the bees inside
if the trees died.

We once had a very tall, 46" DBH buckeye that fell down in a windstorm that
had housed wild bees for the living memory of neighbors in their 60s.

I don't think we ever had a lot of serious competition between honey bees and
other native wildlife.......if there is one thing we seem to have plenty of
in WV it is hollow trees and cavities.

Russ

-----original post------

From the time you first noticed the decline in honey bee populations until
you saw them no more was what kind of time period?

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/threads/bees_and_trees.htm 

Re: Buying Standing Timber = Destructive Highgrading & Ripping Off Landowners    Fores-@aol.com
   Sep 09, 2003 05:21 PDT 
ENTS:

In terms of proof of degradation of the forest and lowering of productivity
by high grading....I have one suggestion from WV that may be able to be
duplicated in Massachusetts...

During the past 14 years, I have cruised inventoried and developed Forest
Stewardship Plans for over 120 parcels of property in multiple WV counties
covering over 20,000 acres.

During that time I have inventoried properties that have not had any
harvesting for over 100 years......including removal of dead chestnut and properties
that have been regularly harvested on 20 year cycles. In earlier harvested
stands, the very best timber quality I have encountered is on old tracts where
there was a sawmill set and the property was clearcut.

However, I am a stats nut and have found that in older stands where
harvesting has not taken place since the 1930s, more valuable species such as red oak
typically represent at least 25% of the basal area, beech is normally under 2%
and species like red maple represent 3% or less....in older stands where
hickory is present, hickory is rarely more than 10-15%. Cull volume in all areas
(excepting those with repeated burns) rarely exceeds 10% of basal area and
normally runs around 5%....I have encountered dozens of properties that meet these
criteria.

In nearly all situations and circumstances where logging has taken place
within the past 25 years....since the advent of self loaders, larger log trucks,
decent bridges, paved roads and very large, permanent sawmills, evidence of
forest degradation from severe highgrading is too evident to ignore. I have
cruised dozens of tracts in this category that have numerous red oak stumps but an overstory that is typically less than 1% red oak...with no red oak regen. In these tracts, hickory BA can run as high as 40%, cull BA is very often 35%+ and beech and red maple that comprised less than 5% of the preharvest stand represent up to 60% of the growing stock.

I could go on and on but if someone would like to glean proof or info from
some of my cruises, I would be willing to copy and send some of this stuff out.

I am going to be racing to MA for my nieces wedding in Shelburne and will be
there between 9/19 and 9/21. If there is anyone interested in some of the BS
I have accumulated....please let me know what sort of info might be
useful...however, I do not do the fancy computer stuff that Karl is famous for.....the numbers are obvious as they are. Friday morning September 19 I could meet with someone to deliver some of the info I have.

Russ Richardson

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/threads/highgrading.htm 

Understory Plants   Fores-@aol.com
  Jan 13, 2004 15:43 PST 
Lisa:

I read with great interest your list of items that you will be documenting in
relationship to the pine trees at Mohawk Trail State Forest.

I would encourage that you also try to assess the diversity and vigor of the
understory vegetation on the site as well.

In my work as a forester, I continue to learn about the identification and
management of medicinal plants found in the forest understory and many other
intricate aspects of the microclimates and plant communities that can exist on
the forest floor beneath some of these old forest areas.

In some instances, especially on hardwood sites where logging has been absent
for over a hundred years...or never harvested at all, there can be plant
populations and communities that rival the significance of the trees that tower
above.

Over the years, I have had the opportunity and privilege to walk through many
fine patches of old timber and have found a serious correlation between the
health and diversity of understory plants and the trees growing above. It is
often possible to find large, old healthy looking trees in a park like setting
where the forest floor is bare. However, an area of old trees with a heavy
ground cover that consists of multiple fern and moss species, herbaceous growth
represented by several fertiltiy-loving herbaceous species is something worth
noting.

Russ Richardson

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/fieldtrips/mass_mtsf/mtsf04.htm 

Red Oak    Fores-@aol.com
   Oct 20, 2003 06:46 PDT 
Bob:

I can say that I have never actually measured the heights of some of the
tallest red oak trees I have encountered. I have sold a number of red oak trees
that had over 100 feet of merchantable height in sawlogs. In a tree that big
it would likely mean a 14" tip because anything smaller would normally fracture
and shatter into unmerchantable pieces when it hit the ground! The largest
red oak I have ever sold had a circumference of approximately 15.2 feet. The
tree had 120 growth rings at stump (ground) level. On that property, I left
larger and better Legacy trees!

In West Virginia, red oak can grow to proportions I would have never imagined
when I worked in New England.

I know you remember the patch of red oak at my parents farm in Shelburne.
That is about the largest and highest quality red oak I have for comparison to
what I encounter in WV but here follows.

There is great variability in how RO grows in the state with the very highest
quality and most valuable red oak coming from the mountain counties of
eastern West Virginia. In those areas, on the very best sites, red oak will have
what appears to be juvenile bark for up to 80 or possibly 100 years. In those
areas it is very rare to encounter any sawtimber sized red oak with less than
50 feet (three logs) of very high quality lumber with 65 to 80 feet of quality
logs far more likely. In those areas, stands that are 35 to 40% red oak can
be found with volumes over 15,000 board feet per acre common for 60-70 year old
stands. Sustained growth rates of 4 rings per inch are common.

In the western and central part of the state where I am the trees are
different and typically average between 40 and 65 feet of high quality wood with
56-60 feet (3.5 logs) far more likely. However, in the western or central part of
the state, diameter growth is normally faster with 3 rings per inch very
common with dominant red oaks typically growing annual rings that are .4 inches or 
.8" per year diameter growth.

Veneer buyers like the somewhat slower growth of the mountain red oak and the
price is comparatively higher.

In terms of growing the stuff. There are all sorts of variations. There are
places where the RO regeneration is fantastic with literally hundreds of
stems per acre with other places where there are none.......
depends upon how many times it has been high graded.

Russ   

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/species/sp_threads/white_oak_threshold.htm 

Black Walnut   Fores-@aol.com
  Oct 01, 2003 08:16 PDT 
Bob:

In central West Virginia, black walnut is relatively common. In many of the
old farms, the trees were often the only shade trees left in pastures and they
can be encountered in the woodland of any farm that has decent growing sites.

Traditionally, the tree was cut so hard that large, high quality black walnut
trees are difficult to find.

The most significant use for black walnut for decades was in gun stocks.
There are numerous stories among WV gun collectors that can date W.W.I era German
weaponry to when the great walnut embargo was in full effect. There are also
stories of trains loaded with stumps dug from WV pastures for gun stocks as
part of past patriotic and commercial ventures.

At this time, I am involved with marking a commercial thinning on fertile
sites where, for a few exceptional acres the residual stand will consist of
nearly pure 14-22" DBH walnut with scattered cherry and red oak of similar size
mixed in.

Generally speaking, pure stands of walnut are uncommon but I have inventoried
properties with cove site stands of over 100 acres in size where the walnut
proportion has been as large as 38% of basal area. In most such stands, the
trees were not planted but seeded into situations where the land was pastured
(for as long as 150 years). A normal/natural black walnut stand would have as
associated species, red and American elm, basswood, redbud, hackberry, cherry,
sassafras and persimmon.

Very often, butternut trees in significant numbers and in varying states of
decline from butternut canker blight can be found associated with black walnut
stands.

Since the advent of plastic gun stocks, the walnut business has really fallen
on hard times. Although it is a very beautiful, durable and extremely easy
wood to work with and is a component of some of the finest furniture ever
created, I really think the long term use of black walnut for weaponry helped to
keep the price artificially high for generations.

Black walnut shells have uses in certain industrial polishing compounds.

My favorite black walnut trait is watching the wood from a freshly cut tree
change color when it is exposed to the air.

There are variations in the color, texture and acid content in the fruit and
the best-flavored nuts are now considered to be from the Missouri area where
commercial black walnut nut production is centered.

The WV Department of Ag used to have a traveling walnut husker that went to
various areas of the state. In each participating county, for several days
each autumn, pickup trucks would be lined up with their bodies loaded with heaps
of sacked up walnuts waiting to get them husked and weighed. That program
ended when Missouri said they no longer wanted nuts from WV and Maryland.


Next weekend, October 9-11, the 49th Annual, WV Black Walnut Festival is
being held in Spencer, WV. Spencer is about 15 miles from Crummies Creek.

Russ Richardson

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/species/sp_threads/black_walnuts.htm 

Log Length   Fores-@aol.com
  Nov 06, 2003 08:00 PST 
Bob:

I have never actually sat down until just now to toss out some of those
height numbers. I know a couple of big tree nuts in WV who are always hunting for
records but there is no one I am aware of measuring maximum tree heights in WV
with the degree of accuracy of ENTS.

In terms of several species of trees, merchantable height often is a very
good indication of total tree height. In most cases, especially dealing with
some of the more valuable hardwoods, merchantable height often stops where limbs
or branches begin...red oaks and yellow poplars (plus cucumber and basswood),
black cherry and walnut are the only trees that are regularly used to a tip
end smaller than 12."

Before I do a chart, taper, relative a couple of measured examples from past
timber sales....top wood and limb wood above merchantable height is generally
30 to 50 additional height but can easily be 60' depending upon utilization
specs or local markets.

black oak 18" DBH.... diameter at 54' (end of clean stem) 16"

yellow poplar 20" DBH.... diameter at 115' 12".......rest of stem shattered
when it fell

I almost never measure total tree height but I can sure tell when I'm in a
100' woods......it really doesn't have to be that big or old and it is not that
uncommon.

From past experience......for WV all species except soft hardwoods
merchantable top diameter is historically 12" (10" in a very competitive market),
poplars now utilized to 8" but historically 11-12" for black cherry now 10" (or
smaller to 7")

Maximum log height          WV          Common          MA/NE
Species                                    WV log height    
Red oak                         105'          75'                     55'
White oak                      90'             75'                    45'
Black oak                       100'           75'                     45'
Chestnut oak                   90+            75'              25-30'          
Yellow poplar                   125+           100+               40'           
(Whately, MA)
Black cherry                       105+   (10" tip) 85'             50'   
White pine                  110-120   (12" tip dia) 100'         100+
Sugar maple                  80'             65'                         48+
Red maple                      90+'         75'                         60+
Butternut                       78+          n/a                       50'
Shagbark hickory           100+            80'                      45+
Sycamore                    120+           110+                      100+

Common merchantable heights are not necessarily typical merchantable heights.
Typical heights for red oaks are around 60,' typical heights for poplars are
around 75' and typical heights for sugar maple is between 50 and 55'. As a
general rule (if there is one) typical tree heights are about 75-80% of common
maximum with absolute measured maximum about 125% of common maximum.

Personally, I have seen very few trees that had a Doyle log scale greater
than 4,000 board feet but many loggers I have worked with have told of cutting
poplars with over 8,000 board feet and nearly everyone seems to have a story
about a 5,000 to 6,000 board foot red oak. I know a forester for a timber
company that sold an 84" DBH black walnut from company lands for $25,000.....and the
tree turned out to be a 100+ foot chimney! I have sold timber in the past to
a sawmill in Ohio that has a special saw to quarter logs that are greater
than 60" in diameter. The last time I was there, I saw a yellow poplar butt log
that was nearly 8' in diameter........it had grown along the banks of the Ohio
River and had multiple years of 1.25" growth rings.

I am currently working on a timber sale on a tract of land that was heavily
logged about 40-45 years ago. Although many of the trees are not extremely
large, there are some red oaks and poplars between 30 and 38." Scattered
throughout the tract are scattered Eastern white pine trees that run between 24 and
30" DBH with most of them hollow and fire-scarred. All of the white pines I
have tallied so far have had a minimum of 4 16 foot logs....a couple of culls
would have had 6 logs and a 32" pine tree that has about 6.5 logs of
merchantable wood also sports a very nice hawk nest. The pine was retained for the
benefit of the hawks. Retained trees immediately surrounding the hawk pine include
red and white oak, beech and hickory that are all of a similar size. Hawks
always tend to find the best tree on a 1000 acres of land and plop their nest
in the middle of it.

I had an earlier sale this year where there were a large number of oaks,
including, red, white and black oaks in excess of 8' CBH....the same sale had a
white ash nearly 11' CBH. Almost none of the timber in the sale was over 90
years old!

I leave the really big ones! I have some very nice 12-15" CBH red oak and
white oaks that were set asides as legacy areas on past timber sales. If you
ever make it down to this part of the world, I'll take you to a place close to
Weston where I had the opportunity to leave some of the largest and highest
quality trees I have seen for several species.....I also left some incredible
culls including cucumber, white oak, chestnut oak, black gum and red oak in
excess of 15' CBH.   

It really isn't until I am back in Massachusetts that I realize how different
our woods really are. I am far more likely to encounter over sized trees in
WV than I ever expected in New England but the likelihood of encountering "old
growth" here is rare.......however, I have a close by neighbor to Crummies
Creek who works for the Nature Conservancy and claims to have some 150+ year old
forest on their family's 500+ acre farm. The only close by old growth patch
I know for certain was devastated by an ice storm we had last February, in
that area, several red oaks and poplars in excess of 10' CBH were damaged and
killed.


Russ Richardson

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/threads/log_length.htm 

Basswoods    Fores-@aol.com
   Nov 05, 2003 18:52 PST 
ENTS:

What is the accepted maximum height for basswood. I have a small (20" DBH)
basswood that is closing in on 130' tall. It is a sample tree I'm monitoring
for growth.

In central WV I have encountered quite a number of healthy (until they were
harvested) second growth basswoods over 10' CBH. I am working on a timber sale
at this time where a number of the basswood are taller than the more common
yellow poplar.

Russ Richardson

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/species/sp_threads/basswood.htm 

RE: Basswoods    Will Blozan
   Nov 06, 2003 04:27 PST 
Russ,

As far as I can recall:

Tilia americana- 128.7' Zoar (2003)
Tilia heterophylla- 148.6' Smokies (2003)

If you have T. americana you may have a species record!

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/species/sp_threads/basswood.htm 

Experiencing a Forest    Fores-@aol.com
   Aug 20, 2005 15:25 PDT 
Jess:

I think that every type of forest we have is best experienced in person. It
isn't just the height or girth of the trees although it is never far from my
mind. The other attributes I try to notice range from song birds, wildlife
and understory vegetation to the soil fertility and local land use history.
I'm kinda a fan of woods as a "whole package" and I enjoy the detail of your
trip descriptions immensely.

Russ

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/musings/forest_experiences.htm 

Butternut in West Virginia   Fores-@aol.com
  Aug 10, 2003 13:49 PDT 
Hi all:

In much of West Virginia, butternut can still commonly be found but nearly
all trees are badly cankers and dying from butternut canker blight.

Since being in WV I have found very few butternut trees in excess of 20" DBH
or more than 90' tall. A few years ago, I had a dead butternut salvaged from
a sale that sawed out 375 board feet of lumber. That tree was not large in
diameter but had very little taper as they got 72' of logs to a 10" tip. At
this time, it has become nearly impossible to locate a completely healthy
butternut tree.

Although we still get some very good seed years....2003 looks like a real
winner.

In WV, butternut is pretty much considered commercially extinct. The WV DoF
has a very good price that they pay for butternuts seeds for the state
nursery.

The only really healthy butternut trees I have encountered in the past few
years have been Japanese butternuts.

Russ Richardson

http://www.nativetreesociety.org/species/sp_threads/butternut_in_west_virginia.htm 

Logging Activity   Fores-@aol.com
  Jul 12, 2006 04:14 PDT 
It really depends upon where you are as to whether you see much logging or
trucking activity in WV. By the sounds of things you spend most of your time
in the mountains of eastern WV. In most of the state the lumber/timber
industry is in the worst shape it has been in since the 1970s and things are not
well at all. WV has more substandard and low weight bridges that any state in
the entire USA and most heavy truck traffic, including logging trucks have
limited roads they can freely drive on,including interstates....if you see any
trucks headed east on I-68 with big logs chances are they are headed for
Baltimore, MD....so many unprocessed logs are exported from the port of
Baltimore that (with creative accounting) the entire state of Maryland has a larger
value forest products industry than nearly any state in the eastern US.

WV forestland is over 80% privately owned and increasing as insurance
companies and real estate speculators buy up large tracts of land formerly owned
by large multinationals like Mead/WestVaco, International Paper and Georgia
Pacific....in the last 10 years 40,000,000 acres (half of all such land in the
US) of commercial forest has been sold and companies such as IP which was the
largest landowner in th World a few years ago now owns no land in the US.

The whole issue of the future of private forestland ownership and industrial
mismanagement will likely come to a head some time in the next 30 or 40
years.

Russ